The Courthouse Cafe Menu

224 Blackmur Dr, Water Valley, MS 38965, United States
$$$ Cafe
(39 Reviews)
Price Range $1–10

Welcome to The Courthouse Cafe, a hidden gem nestled in Water Valley, Mississippi. This charming cafe offers an eclectic menu that caters to all tastes, highlighting classic coffee concoctions and delightful meal options that keep customers coming back for more.

  • Coffee Classics: Indulge in an Affogato or a rich Cappuccino, expertly crafted to brighten your day.
  • Bingo Night Menu: Dive into the Pitmaster for only $20—the perfect blend of flavor and satisfaction.
  • Event Menu: Savor the Taco Trio or try their renowned Jailhouse Burger, loaded with grilled onions and melty cheeses.

Locals rave about the fresh ingredients and friendly service. From the welcoming atmosphere to the delectable lattes and the breakfast burger that packs a punch with fresh veggies, The Courthouse Cafe is a must-visit. Make sure to stop by for a memorable meal!

Full Menu - Lunch

  • Apple Butter Turkey Sandwich

    Turkey, Apple Slices, Apple Butter, Swiss Cheese & Toasted on Sourdough Bread.

    US$10.00
  • The BailBurger

    Our BailBurger is two smashed ground beef patties, seasoned & marinated with our house recipe. It comes fully dressed with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Pickles, Cheddar, Swiss, and our house made mayo based condiment.

    US$11.99
  • BarbeCuban

    Deli sliced Ham, BBQ Pulled Pork, Thick Cut Bacon, Lettuce, Swiss & Creole Mustard, Mayo and a touch of Apple Butter.

    US$13.00
  • Berry Vs. Chicken Salad

    The Berry Vs. Chicken Salad is filled with legalicious flavors! Spinach, Lettuce, Cucumber, Cilantro, Grape Tomatoes, Strawberries, Blueberries, Granola, Almonds, Pecans, Feta Cheese, & our house Redwine vinaigrette dressing!

    US$13.99
  • Bonded Out Turkey

    Sliced Oven Roasted Turkey, Bacon, Avocado, Red Onions, Mayonnaise & PepperJack Cheese

    US$9.50
  • Courthouse Club Sandwich

    Ham, Turkey, Bacon, Swiss, Cheddar, Lettuce, Marinated Tomatoes, Mayo & Honey Mustard served on sourdough bread and toasted. Available as a wrap as well.

    US$10.75
  • Chicken Avocado Melt

    Grilled Chicken Swiss, Spinach, Avocado, & Chipotle Sauce served as a wrap or on sourdough bread & toasted.

    US$11.75
  • Capitol Offense Queso Fries

    Sharable portion of Waffle Fries loaded with Grilled Chicken, Queso, & Buffalo Sauce. Garnished with Bruschetta & Chives.

    US$11.99
  • Cheese Quesadillas

    Spinach, Monterrey Jack, Cheddar, Queso, & Asadero cheese.

    US$8.00
  • Chicken Avocado Quesadilla

    Grilled Chicken, Buffalo Ranch, Lettuce, Marinated Tomatoes, & Swiss Cheese folded into a Spinach Tortilla

    US$12.75
  • Chicken Quesadilla

    Grilled Chicken, Colby Jack, Queso, & Mozzarella Cheese Blend, Spinach, & Mild Buffalo Ranch.

    US$9.75
  • DELUX Grilled Chicken Wrap

    Grilled Chicken, 3 slices of Bacon, Spinach, Tomatoes, Swiss, Cheddar, Jalapeños, Buffalo Ranch, & served as a wrap and toasted to perfection.

    US$12.75
  • Gourmet Grilled Cheese

    Cheddar, Swiss, Colby Jack and Toasted to perfection on Sourdough

    US$8.00
  • Grilled Chicken

    Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Marinated Tomatoes, Swiss, & Ranch.

    US$9.50
  • Jailbird Club

    Grilled Chicken with crispy Bacon, fresh Lettuce, house marinated Tomatoes, Mozzarella cheese, & Red Onions wrapped in a delicious flat bread.

    US$10.75
  • NYC BLT

    A generous amount of Flavorful Bacon, Deliciously Marinated Tomatoes, Fresh Lettuce, & mayo served on Sourdough Bread & toasted to perfection.

    US$10.50
  • Turkey Or Ham Sandwich

    Ham or Turkey Sandwich with lettuce, tomatoes, Swiss & Cheddar, Mayonnaise, and served on toasted Sourdough.

    US$9.99

Full Menu - Breakfast

  • Breakfast Burger
    US$11.99
  • The Avocado Indictment

    Eggs, Bacon Strips, Chedder & Swiss Cheese & Avocado served as a sandwich on toasted Sourdough bread, or sub the toast for a plain Bagel, or a seasoned Everything Bagel.

  • Badgering Biscuit

    Light, Fluffy & Buttery Biscuit made in house. They’re delicious as is, but add an egg, cheese or meat if you’d like.

    US$2.50
  • Breakfast Quesadillas

    Eggs, Ham, Bacon, & Pepper Jack Cheese served on a flour tortilla.

    US$9.75
  • French Toast

    Three Large Texas Toast Slices with Brown sugar Cinnamon, Maple flavoring and griddled to perfection. Topped with Powdered Sugar, Strawberries & Blueberries.

    US$12.99
  • Hotcake Summons

    A stack of 2 or 4 fluffy & delicious pancakes made from our house recipe.

  • Peanut Butter & Justice

    Grilled Peanut Butter & Jelly on Sourdough Bread.

    US$5.99
  • I Plead The Pesto Bagel

    Everything Bagel, with Pesto, Cream Cheese, Turkey, and an over easy Egg between the buns.

    US$6.25
  • The Jailhouse Club

    Ham, Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Swiss & Cheddar and an Egg over medium on an Everything Bagel,

    US$11.75
  • The Subpoena Scramble

    Two Scrambled Eggs mixed with Thick Cut Bacon pieces, Smoked Ham, and a four cheese blend with a side of Toast or a Biscuit

    US$5.99
  • The Testimonial Wrap

    Spinach, Scrambled Eggs, Bacon, & Shredded Cheese. Toasted until golden brown & crispy on griddle.

    US$6.75
  • Breakfast Plate

    Single: One Egg, One Piece of Bacon or Sausage & one slice of Texas Toast or Biscuit. Double: Two Eggs, two pieces of Bacon or Sausages, & Two Slices of Texas Toast or Two Biscuits .

  • Side Of Eggs (2 Eggs)
    US$2.75
  • Slice Of Toast (1 Slice)
    US$0.75
  • Three Strips Of Bacon (SIDE)
    US$4.25
  • Sausage Patty
    US$1.49
  • Bagel With Cream Cheese
    US$3.50

Full Menu - Sides

  • SIDE: Seasoned Fries
    US$2.99
  • SIDE: Potato Salad
    US$2.99
  • SIDE: Chips - Small Bag

    Choose from our assortment of chips at checkout. If ordering Takeout, select your chips upon arrival, as they will not be in the bag.

    US$1.50
  • SIDE: Bacon Strip (1)
    US$1.67
  • SIDE: Toast (1)
    US$1.50
  • SIDE: Eggs (1)
    US$1.75
  • SIDE: Side Salad
    US$3.50
  • SIDE: Seasonal Fruit
    US$3.50
  • Biscuit
    US$2.50
  • Red Smashed Potatoes
    US$2.99

Full Menu - Specialty Lattes

  • Probable Cause

    The Perfect blend of Caramel, Chocolate Espresso & Milk.

  • Objection; Hearsay

    Coconut & Vanilla Latte

  • Overrulled

    For our Reese’s lovers, Peanut Butter & Chocolate Latte!

  • Reasonable Doubt

    Where Caramel meets the sophisticated charm of French Vanilla

  • Calls For Speculations

    Rich Caramel Pecan, and velvety Chocolate flavors.

  • Guilty As Charged

    A delightful fusion of Toasted Marshmallow & rich Chocolate

  • Badgering The Witness

    Where White Chocolate meets the rich embrace of Caramel.

  • Not That I Recall

    A delightful blend of Ground Cinnamon & Hazelnut

  • The Verdict

    Smooth Flavors of Hazelnut & White Chocolate

  • Latte

Full Menu - Coffee Classics

  • Affogato

    Espresso Poured over a scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream

    US$3.75
  • Americano

    Espresso & Water

    US$3.50
  • Black Eye

    Drip Coffee with a shot of Espresso, or two!

  • Breve

    Espresso with Steamed Half & Half

  • Cappuccino

    A thick layer of Foamed Milk over a mixture of Steamed milk & Espresso.

  • Chai
  • Dirty Chai
  • Cold Brew
  • Con Panno

    Espresso & Whip Cream

  • Cortado

    Espresso & just a splash of milk

  • Drip Coffee

    Regular Joe!

    US$3.25
  • Espresso Shot
    US$2.50
  • Flat White
  • Frappe
  • Latte
  • Macchiato

    Espresso with a splash of milk

  • Mocha

Full Menu - Drinks

  • Sweet Tea - 1 Refill
    US$2.50
  • Unsweet Tea - 1 Refill
    US$2.50
  • Half & Half Tea - 1 Refill
    US$2.50
  • Ice Water
    US$0.50
  • Coke
    US$1.50
  • Diet Coke
    US$1.50
  • Dr. Pepper
    US$1.50
  • Sprite
    US$1.50
  • Chocolate Milk
    US$2.00
  • Hot Chocolate 16oz
    US$2.50
  • Earl Grey Hot Tea
    US$3.00
  • Orange Juice
    US$2.00
  • Bottled Water
    US$1.50
  • Cup Of Ice
    US$0.50
  • Sparking Water
    US$3.00
  • Pinot Grigio
    US$4.00
  • Coke Zero
    US$1.50
  • Michelob
    US$5.00
  • Miller Lite
    US$5.00
  • Chardonnay
    US$4.00
  • Bottled Coke
    US$3.00

Full Menu - Bingo Night

  • Pitmaster
    US$20.00

Lunch

  • Apple Butter Turkey Sandwich

    Turkey, Apple Slices, Apple Butter, Swiss Cheese & Toasted on Sourdough Bread.

    US$10.00
  • The BailBurger

    Our BailBurger is two smashed ground beef patties, seasoned & marinated with our house recipe. It comes fully dressed with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Pickles, Cheddar, Swiss, and our house made mayo based condiment.

    US$11.99
  • BarbeCuban

    Deli sliced Ham, BBQ Pulled Pork, Thick Cut Bacon, Lettuce, Swiss & Creole Mustard, Mayo and a touch of Apple Butter.

    US$13.00
  • Berry Vs. Chicken Salad

    The Berry Vs. Chicken Salad is filled with legalicious flavors! Spinach, Lettuce, Cucumber, Cilantro, Grape Tomatoes, Strawberries, Blueberries, Granola, Almonds, Pecans, Feta Cheese, & our house Redwine vinaigrette dressing!

    US$13.99
  • Bonded Out Turkey

    Sliced Oven Roasted Turkey, Bacon, Avocado, Red Onions, Mayonnaise & PepperJack Cheese

    US$9.50
  • Courthouse Club Sandwich

    Ham, Turkey, Bacon, Swiss, Cheddar, Lettuce, Marinated Tomatoes, Mayo & Honey Mustard served on sourdough bread and toasted. Available as a wrap as well.

    US$10.75
  • Chicken Avocado Melt

    Grilled Chicken Swiss, Spinach, Avocado, & Chipotle Sauce served as a wrap or on sourdough bread & toasted.

    US$11.75
  • Capitol Offense Queso Fries

    Sharable portion of Waffle Fries loaded with Grilled Chicken, Queso, & Buffalo Sauce. Garnished with Bruschetta & Chives.

    US$11.99
  • Cheese Quesadillas

    Spinach, Monterrey Jack, Cheddar, Queso, & Asadero cheese.

    US$8.00
  • Chicken Avocado Quesadilla

    Grilled Chicken, Buffalo Ranch, Lettuce, Marinated Tomatoes, & Swiss Cheese folded into a Spinach Tortilla

    US$12.75
  • Chicken Quesadilla

    Grilled Chicken, Colby Jack, Queso, & Mozzarella Cheese Blend, Spinach, & Mild Buffalo Ranch.

    US$9.75
  • DELUX Grilled Chicken Wrap

    Grilled Chicken, 3 slices of Bacon, Spinach, Tomatoes, Swiss, Cheddar, Jalapeños, Buffalo Ranch, & served as a wrap and toasted to perfection.

    US$12.75
  • Gourmet Grilled Cheese

    Cheddar, Swiss, Colby Jack and Toasted to perfection on Sourdough

    US$8.00
  • Grilled Chicken

    Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Marinated Tomatoes, Swiss, & Ranch.

    US$9.50
  • Jailbird Club

    Grilled Chicken with crispy Bacon, fresh Lettuce, house marinated Tomatoes, Mozzarella cheese, & Red Onions wrapped in a delicious flat bread.

    US$10.75
  • NYC BLT

    A generous amount of Flavorful Bacon, Deliciously Marinated Tomatoes, Fresh Lettuce, & mayo served on Sourdough Bread & toasted to perfection.

    US$10.50
  • Turkey Or Ham Sandwich

    Ham or Turkey Sandwich with lettuce, tomatoes, Swiss & Cheddar, Mayonnaise, and served on toasted Sourdough.

    US$9.99

Breakfast

  • Breakfast Burger
    US$11.99
  • The Avocado Indictment

    Eggs, Bacon Strips, Chedder & Swiss Cheese & Avocado served as a sandwich on toasted Sourdough bread, or sub the toast for a plain Bagel, or a seasoned Everything Bagel.

  • Badgering Biscuit

    Light, Fluffy & Buttery Biscuit made in house. They’re delicious as is, but add an egg, cheese or meat if you’d like.

    US$2.50
  • Breakfast Quesadillas

    Eggs, Ham, Bacon, & Pepper Jack Cheese served on a flour tortilla.

    US$9.75
  • French Toast

    Three Large Texas Toast Slices with Brown sugar Cinnamon, Maple flavoring and griddled to perfection. Topped with Powdered Sugar, Strawberries & Blueberries.

    US$12.99
  • Hotcake Summons

    A stack of 2 or 4 fluffy & delicious pancakes made from our house recipe.

  • Peanut Butter & Justice

    Grilled Peanut Butter & Jelly on Sourdough Bread.

    US$5.99
  • I Plead The Pesto Bagel

    Everything Bagel, with Pesto, Cream Cheese, Turkey, and an over easy Egg between the buns.

    US$6.25
  • The Jailhouse Club

    Ham, Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Swiss & Cheddar and an Egg over medium on an Everything Bagel,

    US$11.75
  • The Subpoena Scramble

    Two Scrambled Eggs mixed with Thick Cut Bacon pieces, Smoked Ham, and a four cheese blend with a side of Toast or a Biscuit

    US$5.99
  • The Testimonial Wrap

    Spinach, Scrambled Eggs, Bacon, & Shredded Cheese. Toasted until golden brown & crispy on griddle.

    US$6.75
  • Breakfast Plate

    Single: One Egg, One Piece of Bacon or Sausage & one slice of Texas Toast or Biscuit. Double: Two Eggs, two pieces of Bacon or Sausages, & Two Slices of Texas Toast or Two Biscuits .

  • Side Of Eggs (2 Eggs)
    US$2.75
  • Slice Of Toast (1 Slice)
    US$0.75
  • Three Strips Of Bacon (SIDE)
    US$4.25
  • Sausage Patty
    US$1.49
  • Bagel With Cream Cheese
    US$3.50

Sides

  • SIDE: Seasoned Fries
    US$2.99
  • SIDE: Potato Salad
    US$2.99
  • SIDE: Chips - Small Bag

    Choose from our assortment of chips at checkout. If ordering Takeout, select your chips upon arrival, as they will not be in the bag.

    US$1.50
  • SIDE: Bacon Strip (1)
    US$1.67
  • SIDE: Toast (1)
    US$1.50
  • SIDE: Eggs (1)
    US$1.75
  • SIDE: Side Salad
    US$3.50
  • SIDE: Seasonal Fruit
    US$3.50
  • Biscuit
    US$2.50
  • Red Smashed Potatoes
    US$2.99

Specialty Lattes

  • Probable Cause

    The Perfect blend of Caramel, Chocolate Espresso & Milk.

  • Objection; Hearsay

    Coconut & Vanilla Latte

  • Overrulled

    For our Reese’s lovers, Peanut Butter & Chocolate Latte!

  • Reasonable Doubt

    Where Caramel meets the sophisticated charm of French Vanilla

  • Calls For Speculations

    Rich Caramel Pecan, and velvety Chocolate flavors.

  • Guilty As Charged

    A delightful fusion of Toasted Marshmallow & rich Chocolate

  • Badgering The Witness

    Where White Chocolate meets the rich embrace of Caramel.

  • Not That I Recall

    A delightful blend of Ground Cinnamon & Hazelnut

  • The Verdict

    Smooth Flavors of Hazelnut & White Chocolate

  • Latte

Coffee Classics

  • Affogato

    Espresso Poured over a scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream

    US$3.75
  • Americano

    Espresso & Water

    US$3.50
  • Black Eye

    Drip Coffee with a shot of Espresso, or two!

  • Breve

    Espresso with Steamed Half & Half

  • Cappuccino

    A thick layer of Foamed Milk over a mixture of Steamed milk & Espresso.

  • Chai
  • Dirty Chai
  • Cold Brew
  • Con Panno

    Espresso & Whip Cream

  • Cortado

    Espresso & just a splash of milk

  • Drip Coffee

    Regular Joe!

    US$3.25
  • Espresso Shot
    US$2.50
  • Flat White
  • Frappe
  • Latte
  • Macchiato

    Espresso with a splash of milk

  • Mocha

Drinks

  • Sweet Tea - 1 Refill
    US$2.50
  • Unsweet Tea - 1 Refill
    US$2.50
  • Half & Half Tea - 1 Refill
    US$2.50
  • Ice Water
    US$0.50
  • Coke
    US$1.50
  • Diet Coke
    US$1.50
  • Dr. Pepper
    US$1.50
  • Sprite
    US$1.50
  • Chocolate Milk
    US$2.00
  • Hot Chocolate 16oz
    US$2.50
  • Earl Grey Hot Tea
    US$3.00
  • Orange Juice
    US$2.00
  • Bottled Water
    US$1.50
  • Cup Of Ice
    US$0.50
  • Sparking Water
    US$3.00
  • Pinot Grigio
    US$4.00
  • Coke Zero
    US$1.50
  • Michelob
    US$5.00
  • Miller Lite
    US$5.00
  • Chardonnay
    US$4.00
  • Bottled Coke
    US$3.00

Bingo Night

  • Pitmaster
    US$20.00

Event Menu - Blues Fest

  • Pancakes
    US$8.75
  • Avocado Indictment
    US$6.75
  • Chicken Quesadilla
    US$9.25
  • Cheese Quesadilla
    US$7.00
  • Chicken Avocado Sandwich
    US$9.25
  • Waffle Fries
    US$4.00
  • Latte
    US$5.00
  • Drink
  • Grilled Cheese
    US$5.00

Event Menu - TACO NIGHT

  • Taco Trio
    US$12.99
  • Quesadilla
  • Bail Burger
    US$11.99

Blues Fest

  • Pancakes
    US$8.75
  • Avocado Indictment
    US$6.75
  • Chicken Quesadilla
    US$9.25
  • Cheese Quesadilla
    US$7.00
  • Chicken Avocado Sandwich
    US$9.25
  • Waffle Fries
    US$4.00
  • Latte
    US$5.00
  • Drink
  • Grilled Cheese
    US$5.00

TACO NIGHT

  • Taco Trio
    US$12.99
  • Quesadilla
  • Bail Burger
    US$11.99